Homemade yogurt is cheaper, fresher and more customizable than store-bought, and a good yogurt maker does the hard part: holding milk at a steady warm temperature for hours while the cultures work. Modern digital models let you set the exact temperature and time, shut off automatically, and even make long-fermented probiotic yogurts.
In this guide we compare five of the best electric yogurt makers, from digital models with adjustable temperature to a Greek yogurt maker with a built-in strainer and a simple budget classic, plus a top-rated Greek yogurt strainer for thicker results.
Quick Recommendations
- Best Overall
Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker – Adjustable 68–131°F, 48-hour timer and two 1-quart glass jars. - Best for Greek Yogurt
Bear Greek Yogurt Maker – Built-in fine-mesh strainer and glass jars. - Best Individual Jars
Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker XL – Twelve 6 oz glass jars for grab-and-go portions. - Best Budget
Euro Cuisine YM80 – Simple, reliable and inexpensive. - Best Greek Yogurt Strainer
Euro Cuisine GY50 – Turns any yogurt into thick Greek yogurt.
Top picks at a glance
Table of contents
List of the Best Yogurt Makers
Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker with Adjustable Temperature (Two 1-Quart Jars)

The Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker is the best-selling yogurt maker on Amazon for good reason. Its digital controls let you set the temperature anywhere from 68°F to 131°F and the time up to 48 hours, which is what you need for long-fermented probiotic yogurts like L. reuteri as well as regular and Greek yogurt. It makes two quarts at a time in glass jars.
Key Features
- Adjustable Temperature: 68°F to 131°F for any culture.
- Up to 48-Hour Timer: Long ferments for probiotic yogurt.
- Two 1-Quart Glass Jars: Two quarts per batch.
- Automatic Shut-Off: Stops when the timer ends.
- Lifetime Warranty: Backed by the brand.
What We Like
- Total Control: Set the exact temperature and time for any recipe.
- Probiotic-Ready: Handles long L. reuteri ferments.
- Best Seller: Thousands of strong ratings.
What We Don’t Like
- Temperature Accuracy Varies: Some owners measure a few degrees off.
- Large Footprint: Needs counter space.
Overall
The Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker is the best yogurt maker overall, with adjustable temperature, a long timer and two quarts of glass jars.
Bear Greek Yogurt Maker with Strainer and Glass Jars

The Bear Yogurt Maker is built for Greek yogurt. It makes yogurt in two 1-quart borosilicate glass jars, then a fine 100-mesh strainer turns it thick and creamy. Preset programs also handle cheese, kefir and fruit wine, and it beeps when it’s done.
Key Features
- Built-In Greek Strainer: Fine 100-mesh for thick yogurt.
- Two 1-Quart Glass Jars: Borosilicate glass.
- Preset Programs: Yogurt, Greek yogurt, cheese, kefir and more.
- Timer up to 14 Hours: With automatic shut-off.
- Stainless Steel Inner Pot: Even heating.
What We Like
- Greek Yogurt Made Easy: Strainer included in the box.
- Versatile: Also makes cheese and kefir.
- Glass Jars: No plastic contact.
What We Don’t Like
- No Temperature Adjustment: Presets only.
- 14-Hour Limit: Too short for long probiotic ferments.
Overall
The Bear Yogurt Maker is the best yogurt maker for Greek yogurt, with a strainer and glass jars included.
Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker XL with 12 Jars

The Ultimate XL makes yogurt in twelve 6-ounce glass jars, so you get ready-made individual portions for breakfasts and lunches all week. It has the same adjustable digital temperature and 48-hour timer as the standard model, with 50% more capacity.
Key Features
- Twelve 6 oz Glass Jars: About 2.25 quarts per batch.
- Adjustable Temperature: Digital control for any culture.
- Up to 48-Hour Timer: For probiotic ferments.
- Automatic Shut-Off: Stops when finished.
- Lifetime Warranty: Backed by Ultimate.
What We Like
- Grab-and-Go Portions: No spooning into containers.
- Large Capacity: A week of yogurt for a family.
- Probiotic-Ready: Long ferments supported.
What We Don’t Like
- Most Expensive: The priciest maker here.
- Big Footprint: Needs a lot of counter space.
Overall
The Ultimate XL is the best yogurt maker with individual jars for families and meal preppers.
Euro Cuisine YM80 Yogurt Maker with Glass Jars

The Euro Cuisine YM80 is the classic budget yogurt maker. Fill seven 6-ounce glass jars, set the lid and let it hold a steady temperature for a few hours. A manual dial reminds you when your batch should be done.
Key Features
- Seven 6 oz Glass Jars: About 42 oz per batch.
- Fixed Temperature: Simple, steady heat for regular yogurt.
- Reminder Dial: Marks when your batch is ready.
- Compact Design: Easy to store.
- Clear Lid: See your yogurt set.
What We Like
- Very Affordable: One of the cheapest ways to start.
- Huge Owner Base: Thousands of ratings.
- Glass Jars: Easy to clean and reuse.
What We Don’t Like
- No Timer or Auto-Off: Set a phone timer to avoid overheating.
- Small Jars: 6 oz portions only.
Overall
The Euro Cuisine YM80 is the best budget yogurt maker for simple, everyday yogurt.
Euro Cuisine GY50 Greek Yogurt Maker Strainer

The Euro Cuisine GY50 isn’t electric, but it is one of the most useful yogurt tools you can buy. Pour in homemade or store-bought yogurt, refrigerate, and the ultra-fine mesh basket strains out the whey to leave thick Greek yogurt. It pairs perfectly with any yogurt maker that doesn’t include a strainer.
Key Features
- Ultra-Fine Mesh Basket: Strains whey without cheesecloth.
- 2-Quart Capacity: Strain a big batch at once.
- Fridge-Friendly: Strains in the refrigerator.
- Non-Electric: No power needed.
- Easy to Clean: Simple three-part design.
What We Like
- Outstanding Ratings: One of the top-rated yogurt products on Amazon.
- Thick Results: Control how thick your Greek yogurt gets.
- Inexpensive: A low-cost upgrade.
What We Don’t Like
- Not a Yogurt Maker: You still need yogurt to strain.
- Takes Hours: Thick Greek yogurt needs time in the fridge.
Overall
The Euro Cuisine GY50 is the best Greek yogurt strainer and a perfect partner for any yogurt maker.
Yogurt Maker Comparison Table
| Model | Capacity | Jars | Temperature Control | Timer / Auto-Off | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ultimate Probiotic | 2 qt | 2 x 1 qt glass | Adjustable 68–131°F | Up to 48 h, auto-off | Most people |
| Bear Greek Yogurt Maker | 2 qt | 2 x 1 qt glass | Presets | Up to 14 h, auto-off | Greek yogurt |
| Ultimate Probiotic XL | 2.25 qt | 12 x 6 oz glass | Adjustable | Up to 48 h, auto-off | Individual portions |
| Euro Cuisine YM80 | 42 oz | 7 x 6 oz glass | Fixed | Reminder dial only | Budget |
| Euro Cuisine GY50 | 2 qt | Strainer basket | Non-electric | N/A | Straining Greek yogurt |
Things to Consider When Choosing a Yogurt Maker
1. Adjustable Temperature
Regular yogurt sets around 108–112°F, but probiotic yogurts like L. reuteri ferment at lower temperatures for much longer. If you want to experiment, choose a maker with adjustable temperature like the Ultimate models.
2. Timer and Auto Shut-Off
A digital timer with automatic shut-off stops yogurt from over-fermenting and turning sour. Basic models need you to set a separate timer.
3. Jars or One Large Container
Individual jars give ready-made portions. One or two large containers are easier to strain into Greek yogurt and to use in recipes.
4. Glass or Plastic
Glass jars don’t absorb odors or stains and are easy to sanitize. Many modern makers now use glass.
5. Greek Yogurt
For thick Greek yogurt, choose a maker with a strainer like the Bear, or add a separate strainer like the Euro Cuisine GY50.
6. Extra Functions
Some makers also handle kefir, soft cheese, fruit wine or natto, which adds value if you enjoy fermenting.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it worth buying a yogurt maker?
If you eat yogurt regularly, yes. Homemade yogurt costs far less than premium store-bought yogurt, has no additives, and you control the tartness, thickness and cultures.
How long does it take to make yogurt in a yogurt maker?
Most regular yogurt sets in about 6 to 12 hours. Longer ferments make tangier yogurt, and some probiotic recipes run 24 to 36 hours.
Can I make Greek yogurt in a yogurt maker?
Yes. Make regular yogurt, then strain it to remove whey. Some makers include a strainer, or you can use one like the Euro Cuisine GY50.
What temperature should a yogurt maker be?
Around 108–112°F is typical for regular yogurt. Some probiotic cultures, like L. reuteri, work best at lower temperatures for longer.
Can I make dairy-free yogurt in a yogurt maker?
Yes. Coconut, almond, cashew and soy milks all work with the right culture and sometimes a thickener. Pair your maker with a nut milk maker for fully homemade dairy-free yogurt.
Conclusion
The Ultimate Probiotic Yogurt Maker is our top pick for its adjustable temperature, 48-hour timer and two quarts of glass jars, while the Bear Yogurt Maker is the easiest way to make Greek yogurt with its built-in strainer. If you want grab-and-go portions, the Ultimate XL makes twelve individual jars.
On a budget, the Euro Cuisine YM80 is a reliable classic, and the Euro Cuisine GY50 strainer turns any batch into thick Greek yogurt. Making plant-based yogurt? See our guide to the best nut milk makers, and store your portions in meal prep containers.
